Skip to content
Celebrity

Michelle Visage Replaces Jennifer Simard in Schmigadoon! for a Run From Dec. 4 to Jan. 31

Michelle Visage will play Mildred Layton in Schmigadoon! on Broadway from Dec. 4, 2026, to Jan. 31, 2027, replacing Jennifer Simard, whose last show in the role is Nov. 29.

Close-up of a woman with long silver-grey wavy hair and dramatic makeup against a pale grey backdrop

Michelle Visage, a longtime judge on RuPaul's Drag Race, will make her Broadway debut in Schmigadoon! as Mildred Layton. Reports published on Nov. 12, 2026 say she takes over the role from Jennifer Simard, whose final performance is Nov. 29.

Visage's engagement runs from Dec. 4, 2026, through Jan. 31, 2027, at the Nederlander Theatre on West 41st Street. New York Theatre Guide describes the engagement as a limited run. The production opened in April 2026 and won four Tony Awards, including Best Musical.

What the November 12 Casting Sets Out

Broadway.com, TheaterMania and New York Theatre Guide each reported the casting on Nov. 12, 2026. Visage plays Mildred Layton, a role Simard has held, and her run begins Dec. 4.

Simard's final performance is Nov. 29, and Visage's run begins Dec. 4. Visage's last scheduled performance in the role is Jan. 31, 2027. New York Theatre Guide describes Simard as a three-time Tony Award nominee. A related New York Theatre Guide headline says Simard succeeds Ana Gasteyer, who is listed as Mildred Layton in that outlet's cast list.

TheaterMania describes Visage as the head judge on RuPaul's Drag Race. Broadway.com calls her a permanent judge on the series.

Visage's Stage and Television Background

Broadway.com describes Visage as a permanent judge on RuPaul's Drag Race since 2011 and a four-time Emmy winner. New York Theatre Guide calls her a 15-year judge and an Emmy Award winner. According to Broadway.com, she rose to fame in the girl group Seduction and later became the lead vocalist of the R&B quartet The S.O.U.L. S.Y.S.T.E.M. She has also competed on Celebrity Big Brother and Strictly Come Dancing.

Both Broadway.com and TheaterMania describe her West End debut in Everybody's Talking About Jamie. The two outlets name her role differently: Miss Wedge on Broadway.com and Miss Hedge on TheaterMania. TheaterMania places the show at the Apollo Theatre.

Her recent stage work includes Tante Hansa in Sea Witch at Theatre Royal Drury Lane, which Broadway.com and TheaterMania both list. Broadway.com also credits her with an appearance in the feature film Stop! That! Train! and with Morticia in The Addams Family, a concert staging opposite Ramin Karimloo. TheaterMania places that Morticia role at the London Palladium.

The Musical and Its Tony Awards

Schmigadoon! is based on Season 1 of the Apple TV+ series, according to New York Theatre Guide, which says Cinco Paul co-created that series with Ken Daurio. Broadway.com credits Paul with the book and score, and Christopher Gattelli with direction and choreography.

The story follows New York doctors Josh and Melissa, who go on a couples' backpacking retreat to revitalize their relationship. After they get lost, they arrive in Schmigadoon, a magical town that resembles a Golden Age musical. Broadway.com says the only way out is to find true love, which may or may not be with each other.

TheaterMania describes the show as a Tony Award-winning musical. The American Theatre Wing's Tony Awards site lists 12 nominations and four wins for the show. New York Theatre Guide says the wins are Best Musical, plus prizes for the book, score and orchestrations. The Tony site lists Doug Besterman and Mike Morris as Best Orchestrations nominees. Broadway.com and New York Theatre Guide both tie the wins to the 2026 Tony Awards.

The Tony site also lists Sara Chase, Ana Gasteyer, Christopher Gattelli and the designers Scott Pask, Linda Cho, Donald Holder and Walter Trarbach among the nominees. Chase is nominated in the leading actress category and Gasteyer in the featured category. Gattelli is nominated for both direction and choreography.

The Principal Cast and Ensemble

Alex Brightman plays Josh Skinner and Sara Chase plays Melissa Gimble. Ann Harada plays Florence Menlove, a role TheaterMania says she reprises from the TV series. Brad Oscar plays Mayor Menlove, Isabelle McCalla plays Emma Tate, Max Clayton plays Danny Bailey, McKenzie Kurtz plays Betsy and Ayaan Diop plays Carson, according to Broadway.com.

Maulik Pancholy plays the Reverend, according to Broadway.com. TheaterMania lists the role as Reverend Layton/Leprechaun.

TheaterMania names 17 additional performers in the company, including Afra Hines, Becca Petersen and Lyrica Woodruff.

“Visage's engagement is a limited run ending Jan. 31, 2027.”

A Sequence of Cast Changes in November and December

The changes come in sequence. Juan Pablo Di Pace plays Doc through Nov. 22, according to Broadway.com. Ivan Hernandez returns to the role on Nov. 24.

A New York Theatre Guide article dated Oct. 6, 2026 says Di Pace replaces Hernandez during a scheduled four-week leave of absence, with his run from Oct. 24 to Nov. 22. Di Pace is known for playing Fernando on Fuller House. A related New York Theatre Guide headline calls his stint a limited run.

Simard's final performance as Mildred Layton is Nov. 29. Visage begins Dec. 4, and her last scheduled performance in the role is Jan. 31, 2027. Visage takes over the Mildred role that Simard leaves.

The Nederlander Run, Dates and Ticket Prices

The Nederlander Theatre is at 208 West 41st Street, between Seventh and Eighth Avenues, in New York, and has 1,235 seats, according to New York Theatre Guide. Visage's engagement is listed there from Dec. 4, 2026, to Jan. 31, 2027.

The Tony Awards site lists the opening at the theatre as April 20, 2026. New York Theatre Guide's explainer gives April 4, 2026, as the start of Broadway performances.

The Tony Awards site and New York Theatre Guide's explainer both list the final performance of the Broadway run as Sept. 6, 2026. A New York Theatre Guide article dated Oct. 6, 2026 gives ticket availability through April 4, 2027. The Sept. 6 date ends the April to September 2026 run, while later listings run to Jan. 31, 2027 and April 4, 2027, so the production's closing date is not confirmed.

Ticket prices also differ. Broadway.com lists tickets from $64.83, while New York Theatre Guide gives $62 as the starting price. New York Theatre Guide lists performances Tuesday through Sunday, with two on Wednesdays and Saturdays and none on Mondays, and notes that the schedule may change.

The show runs about 2 hours 30 minutes including one intermission, and New York Theatre Guide recommends it for ages 10 and up.


Related