Skip to content
Celebrity

How Opening-Night Reviews Split on Lincoln Center's A Few Good Men Revival

Bradley Whitford, Tom Blyth and Krysta Rodriguez opened Aaron Sorkin's courtroom drama at the Vivian Beaumont Theater on Oct. 29, after previews from Oct. 8.

Smiling man with white hair and black-rimmed glasses in a navy jacket and patterned shirt against a dark backdrop.

The Lincoln Center Theater revival of Aaron Sorkin's A Few Good Men officially opened on Oct. 29, 2026, at the Vivian Beaumont Theater. Previews had begun on Oct. 8. Bradley Whitford, Tom Blyth and Krysta Rodriguez lead the company under the direction of Michael Arden.

The play is a courtroom drama set at a naval base. Two Marines are accused in the death of a young Marine at Guantanamo Bay, and the central question is whether they acted alone or on orders from their superior, Lt. Col. Nathan R. Jessep. Opening-night reviews split, from a harsh verdict to a measured one.

Previews From Oct. 8 and an Opening on Oct. 29

Playbill's production listing gives Oct. 8, 2026, as the first preview and Oct. 29 as the official opening. The production plays at the Vivian Beaumont Theater, 150 W. 65th St., in New York.

Opening-night reviews came in two groups. TheWrap and TheaterMania published on Oct. 29, and Time Out published the next day, on Oct. 30.

The listing shows the production as currently running, with performances scheduled from Tuesday through Sunday and the last listed date on Nov. 29. The listing gives no closing date. Time Out and Playbill both give the running time as two hours and 30 minutes, with one intermission.

Whitford, Blyth and Rodriguez in the Lead Roles

Bradley Whitford plays Lt. Col. Nathan R. Jessep. Tom Blyth plays LTJG Daniel Kaffee, and Krysta Rodriguez plays LCDR Joanne Galloway, according to Playbill's cast list. Time Out describes Rodriguez's character as overeager but with real backbone.

In a Broadway.com interview published Oct. 22, Blyth says he grew up on the film and that it was one of the reasons he wanted to become an actor. He hopes the revival will renew interest among a younger generation, many of whom may be meeting the story for the first time.

Reviews of Blyth's performance differ. Time Out finds his charm likable and his confidence tempered by insecurity. TheaterMania calls Blyth practically monochromatic by comparison, and TheWrap's Robert Hofler says Blyth's takedown of Whitford's character is weak.

Reviews are also split on Whitford. Time Out says he captures Jessep's arrogance but not the character's deeper menace. TheaterMania says he doesn't seem comfortable in the fatigues, though it finds an earned satisfaction in the way he and Blyth play the famous moment.

The Supporting Cast and Creative Team

The supporting cast includes Nick Blaemire as LTJG Sam Weinberg, Stephanie Berry as CAPT J. A. Randolph, and John Zdrojeski as 1stLt Jonathan Kendrick. Thom Sesma plays Maj Matthew Markinson, Michael Oberholtzer plays Capt Jack Ross, and Lavel Schley plays LCpl Harold W. Dawson. Christopher Gurr plays CDR Walter Stone, and Billy Eugene Jones plays CAPT Isaac Whitaker.

Playbill's listing names 21 cast members, all marked as original.

Time Out says the ensemble is uniformly good and that Berry plays the judge, reimagined as a Black woman. TheaterMania singles out Zdrojeski as the standout, with an intensity that outshines nearly everyone onstage. It credits Rodriguez and Blaemire with charming work in underwritten roles.

Sorkin wrote the play. Broadway.com describes Arden as a Tony winner. Playbill's creative credits list Dane Laffrey as scenic designer, Japhy Weideman as lighting designer, Alejo Vietti as costume designer, Joshua Reid as sound designer and Gabriel Mann for original music. Casting is by The Telsey Office.

“The production opened on Oct. 29 after previews that began on Oct. 8, at Lincoln Center's Vivian Beaumont Theater.”

Opening-Night Reviews Split on the Play Itself

Robert Hofler's review in TheWrap is the most critical of the three. He calls the play a "creaky old play" and says the plot resolves too conveniently, with the defense case handed to the lawyers when a subordinate informs and then takes his own life. He jokes that Agatha Christie would have solved the problem sometime between her first and second drafts.

Hofler also argues that Jessep's collapse on the witness stand comes just as easily as the rest of the plot. He says Tom Cruise strains credulity in the film, since he is no match for Jack Nicholson. He describes the revival's pitch to theatergoers: since they have already seen the movie, why not see the stage version? He says the play received only one Tony nomination in 1989 and calls that "quite a snub," yet also says the revival makes clear "the Tony Awards got it right."

Adam Feldman's review in Time Out gives the production three stars. He calls it handsome but says it generates little excitement and lacks surprise. He finds a handful of good moments, but nothing so thrilling as the famous courtroom exchange from the 1992 film occurs in the revival. He describes the 1989 script as basic, an early training exercise for Sorkin, and argues the play is less political than it appears.

David Gordon's review in TheaterMania calls the revival a perfectly honorable revival that does not break new ground. He describes the play as more artifact than masterwork and a fascinating look at Sorkin's early work, and he notes its Broadway run of 500 performances. He finds Arden's staging luxurious but not commanding enough to disguise the predictable plot.

The reviews agree on scale. TheWrap calls the set mammoth, and TheaterMania says it has a scale not seen at the Vivian Beaumont since Bartlett Sher's Rodgers & Hammerstein revivals.

Sorkin and Arden on Staging a Script for the Stage

In the Broadway.com interview, Sorkin says he loves it when directors do things in a theater that you can only do in a theater. He feels this production does exactly that.

Arden says the play already works and that his job is to mess it up. He jokes that Charles Dickens is the only other writer he has worked with on a straight play. He says the design was meant to hold a depth that viewers cannot quite grasp.

On staging, Time Out says Arden makes strong use of the Vivian Beaumont's deep playing space, moving from cinematic effects to monumental ones. TheWrap says he keeps scenes moving the way a screenplay would, but that the large set highlights the play's weaknesses. Hofler also notes that Arden usually directs musicals, and that here the singing is replaced by a great deal of shouting from the actors.


Related