How Clawback Rules Recover Executive Pay After an Accounting Restatement
Listed companies must recover certain incentive pay after an accounting restatement, under SEC rules, exchange standards and 2023 deadlines.

A clawback lets a listed company take back incentive pay that its executives have already received. Under the SEC's final rule, adopted on October 26, 2022, the trigger is an accounting restatement. The rule took effect on January 27, 2023, according to the SEC's small-entity compliance guide.
The SEC rule works through the exchanges. National securities exchanges were required to adopt listing standards, and those standards carry the obligations down to individual listed companies. The sections below cover who is covered, what can be recovered, when a board may stop short, how the deadlines were set, how exchanges enforce the standards, and what must be disclosed.
Which Companies Are Covered
The rule applies to domestic and foreign issuers whose securities are listed on a national securities exchange. The SEC guide excludes certain security futures products, standardized options and securities issued by unit investment trusts.
Certain registered investment companies that have not awarded incentive-based compensation in the past three fiscal years do not have to adopt a recovery policy or give the related disclosure.
Husch Blackwell reports that the exchange standards apply to nearly all companies with listed securities, with limited exceptions. It names smaller reporting companies, emerging growth companies, foreign private issuers and controlled companies among those covered.
Husch Blackwell says the policies cover current and former executive officers.
What Pay Can Be Recovered
The target is incentive-based compensation that can be recovered from current or former executive officers in the event the issuer is required to prepare an accounting restatement. The amount to recover is the pre-tax excess of what was received over what would have been received based on the restated figures. Issuers may not indemnify executives against these losses.
The lookback covers the three completed fiscal years immediately before the date the issuer must prepare the restatement. The policy reaches pay received after a person began serving as an executive officer, pay received by a person who served as an executive officer at any time during the performance period, and pay received while the issuer's securities were listed.
The SEC guide says the trigger covers restatements that correct material errors, and restatements that would cause a material misstatement if the errors were left uncorrected in the current period. Husch Blackwell says the triggers include both Big R and Little r restatements.
Under the SEC guide, recovery must occur reasonably promptly. Husch Blackwell says recovery applies regardless of executive officer fault. The recoverable figure is measured against restated numbers, not against anyone's conduct.
When an Issuer May Stop Short
The SEC guide lists three situations in which recovery may be excused. The first is where the direct third-party enforcement expense would exceed the amount recoverable, after a reasonable and documented recovery attempt. The second is where recovery would violate home-country law adopted before November 28, 2022, and the issuer gives the exchange an opinion of home-country counsel. The third is where recovery would likely cause a tax-qualified retirement plan to fail Internal Revenue Code requirements.
Where recovery is impracticable, the issuer reports the amount forgone for each named executive officer and for other executive officers as a group, along with the reason, as described in the disclosure section below.
Dates for the Exchange Standards
The SEC guide lists January 27, 2023 as the date the rule and its amendments took effect, and February 27, 2023 as the date exchanges had to file proposed listing standards. It gives November 28, 2023 as the date by which the listing standards had to be effective.
Husch Blackwell gives these dates for the exchange standards. It reports that the SEC approved the NYSE and Nasdaq standards on June 9, 2023, that they took effect on October 2, 2023, and that companies had until December 1, 2023 to adopt a compliant policy. It describes the December 1 date as 60 days after the October 2 effective date. Debevoise gives the same October 2 effective date and December 1 deadline. Debevoise lists June 9, 2023 as the earlier proposed effective date, which NYSE and Nasdaq replaced with October 2 in amended proposals that the SEC approved on an accelerated basis.
Debevoise says the policy would cover incentive-based compensation received on or after October 2, 2023. The SEC guide sets the lookback at three completed fiscal years before the restatement date.
Debevoise says the revised timeline gives issuers that had not yet prepared a policy more time to comply, and that the change was welcome for issuers that had been working through the summer to finalize their policies.
“The recoverable figure is measured against restated numbers, not against anyone's conduct.”
Exchange Cure Periods and Preparation Steps
Husch Blackwell says a company that fails to comply with the standards faces exchange cure periods before any delisting. At the NYSE, the initial cure period is six months, with a possible additional six months. The NYSE may withhold a cure period or shorten it at its discretion.
At Nasdaq, the cure period is up to 180 days, plus up to 180 more days at the Hearings Panel's discretion if the company appeals a delisting. Husch Blackwell says failure to comply, after notice and cure procedures, can lead to immediate suspension and delisting.
Husch Blackwell lists steps to take before the December 1, 2023 deadline. These include reviewing compensation agreements for provisions that prohibit clawbacks, require clawbacks only in the event of misconduct, allow board or committee discretion, require company-paid insurance, or reduce clawback recovery for amounts paid in taxes. It also covers obtaining board and compensation committee approvals and checking that internal controls can identify triggering events quickly.
The indemnification ban extends to paying for or reimbursing third-party insurance that funds recovery obligations, according to Husch Blackwell.
What Companies Must Disclose
Disclosure falls under Item 402 of Regulation S-K, Form 40-F, Form 20-F and, for listed funds, Form N-CSR. The SEC guide says the disclosures are tagged in Inline XBRL. Where a restatement has triggered a clawback, companies must state the restatement date and the aggregate erroneously awarded compensation, with an analysis of how it was calculated.
If the amount cannot yet be determined, the issuer must say so, explain why, and disclose the amount in its next applicable filing. For measures based on stock price or total shareholder return, the issuer must disclose the estimates used and the methodology.
The issuer must also report the aggregate amount still outstanding at fiscal year-end. For each current and former named executive officer whose amount has been outstanding 180 days or longer after the issuer determined what it owed, the outstanding dollar amount must be shown. Where recovery is impracticable, the issuer discloses the amount forgone for each named executive officer and for other executive officers as a group, along with the reason. If the issuer concludes no recovery was required, it must give a brief explanation.
Husch Blackwell says the policy is filed as an exhibit to the annual report under Item 601(b)(97) of Regulation S-K. It also says companies must check a box on the annual report cover page indicating whether financial statements reflect error corrections and whether any of those corrections require a clawback analysis, and must disclose actions taken under the policy under Item 402(w).



