Skip to content
Neighborhoods

Why NYC Landmark Designation Can Proceed Over an Owner's Objection, Step by Step

A landmark designation can proceed over an owner's objection and changes how most work is approved. Here is the sequence from staff review to the Council's final window.

People stroll and sit among tulip beds and trees in a sunny city park, with a fountain and tall stone buildings behind.

A landmark designation places a building or district under the review of the Landmarks Preservation Commission. Owner consent is not required for the designation, and it changes how most later work on the property is approved.

The process runs through several stages, some with their own notice rules and time limits. It begins with staff research, moves through a Commission vote, then passes to City Planning and the City Council. Owners carry obligations after the designation takes effect, and a 2016 Council bill set deadlines for the Commission's own decisions.

How Designation Starts With Staff Research and Calendaring

Designation begins with the Commission's Research Department, which surveys buildings and neighborhoods. Staff also evaluate requests from the public, submitted as Requests for Evaluation. Surveys help the Commission set priorities for future landmarks and historic districts.

Staff assess whether a property merits consideration in light of agency priorities. If it advances, its photo, a statement of significance and a committee recommendation go to each commissioner for comment.

The Chair then decides whether to seek a public vote to start formal review. Owners are notified if a formal review is planned.

The full Commission votes at a public meeting on whether to schedule a public hearing. This step is called calendaring, and a majority of the commissioners present must approve the motion.

The Public Hearing, Designation Report and Commission Vote

Notice of each public hearing runs in the City Record. The notice goes to the owner, the Department of City Planning, affected community boards and elected officials, and it is posted on the Commission's website. Anyone may testify, and staff give a brief presentation before testimony begins.

While the item is under consideration, research staff prepare a detailed designation report. The owner receives a draft to review and comment on, and commissioners use that report with the public testimony when they decide.

Approval requires a majority of the commissioners, which the Commission puts at six votes. Without six votes in favour, the item is removed from the calendar. Landmark designation takes effect on the vote.

Within 10 days of the vote, the Commission files its final report with the City Council and the City Planning Commission. It also sends designation notices to the owner and to the City Clerk's office.

City Planning and City Council Review After the Vote

The City Planning Commission has 60 days to review the designation and report to the Council on its effects on zoning, projected public improvements and other city development plans. For historic districts, it must hold its own public hearing before issuing that report.

The City Council then has 120 days from the Commission's filing to modify or disapprove the designation, by majority vote. Council approval is not required for a designation to stand.

The Mayor may veto a Council action within five days. The Council may override that veto with a two-thirds vote within 10 days.

Landmark designation takes effect on the Commission's vote, so it is in force while these review periods run.

“Designation does not freeze a building, but most alterations need Commission approval before work begins.”

What Owners Must Get Approved After Designation

Designation does not freeze a building, but most alterations need Commission approval before work begins. That includes reconstruction, demolition and new construction affecting a designated building. The rule applies to individual landmarks and to buildings in historic districts alike.

The Commission reviews proposed changes against its standards of appropriateness, so that the special qualities of designated buildings are not compromised. Owners must follow all permits and conditions attached to an approval. For new construction on a vacant lot or on a building of no significance in a historic district, the Commission has approved designs found appropriate to the district's character.

Some work is exempt. Ordinary exterior repair and upkeep need no permit. Examples include replacing broken window glass and removing small amounts of painted graffiti.

Interior work generally does not need review. The exceptions are work that requires a Buildings Department permit, work that affects the exterior, and work on a designated interior landmark. The Commission can designate interiors.

Owners must also keep the building in a state of good repair. The law protects landmarks from demolition by neglect, which occurs when a building has deteriorated to the point of collapse or significant architectural features are damaged. Owners may be issued a violation if they fail to keep a landmark in a state of good repair. This is comparable to the Buildings Department's safety maintenance requirement.

The Commission cannot require an owner to restore a building to its original appearance or undo changes made before designation. It reviews only the changes an owner proposes.

The Deadlines Set by the 2016 Timeline Bill

In June 2016 the full City Council approved a bill that set deadlines for the Commission to act on calendared items. According to CityLand, the Land Use Committee met on June 7 and the full Council voted on June 8. The bill was Introduction 775 of the 2015 session, sponsored by Council Members David Greenfield and Peter Koo.

For individual, interior and scenic landmarks, the Commission must vote within 12 months of the public hearing, according to CityLand. An item not acted on within that period is removed from the calendar. For historic districts, the limit is 24 months from initial calendaring.

For individual, interior and scenic landmarks, the Commission may extend the deadline by 12 months with the owner's concurrence, if there is sufficient need.

Items calendared before the law takes effect must be acted on within 18 months of its effective date. An owner's consent can add a further 12 months. The effective date has not been confirmed.

The bill was revised before the vote. An earlier version would have allowed 180 days to hold a hearing after calendaring and 180 days after the hearing for a vote. It also carried a five-year moratorium on reconsideration, which the final version removed. Hearings on the earlier version were held in September 2015.

Supporters, including Michael Slattery, president of the Real Estate Board of New York, said the bill would bring greater predictability for property and business owners. Greenfield called it a "good government reform" and said it would curb the Commission's indefinite decision-making. Koo said it would create a predictable timetable with reasonable expectations for communities and property owners.

Opponents, including preservation groups, argued the bill would weaken an under-funded agency and give developers an incentive to delay designations. Landmarks Chair Meenakshi Srinivasan said the timeframes were too short and could undermine the Landmarks Law and the agency's effectiveness, noting that designations sometimes take up to three years. Council Member Rosie Mendez said the timelines were still too short.

The Municipal Art Society objected that owner-concurrence provisions gave individual owners control over public-benefit actions, and that the Council did not provide added funding. The Historic Districts Council said 30 percent of existing designations would not have met the standards, which would have left about 18,000 properties without landmark protection.


Related