Skip to content
Commercial

How CMBS Delinquency Rates Are Counted, and Why the Headline Number Moves

Trepp's headline and seriously delinquent rates, and the matured balloon loans kept outside the headline, affect how CMBS delinquency figures read.

Empty press briefing room with a Ginnie Mae podium, blue backdrop, rows of chairs and charts on easels

A commercial mortgage delinquency rate is a single number built from a count of late loans, and the count depends on the report that publishes it. Trepp and the Mortgage Bankers Association each count delinquencies in their own way, so the same market can produce different rates in different releases.

For readers following office and multifamily debt, the headline in a monthly release is where the reading starts. The categories beneath it show which loans are counted, how many are past their maturity dates, and which lender groups are included.

The Headline Rate Sits Above the Seriously Delinquent Measure

Trepp's report for September 2026 put its headline CMBS delinquency rate at 8.02%, up 17 basis points from August and the highest since November 2020. CRE Daily, which summarized the report on Oct. 5, gives the same figures.

The same report carries a narrower measure, the seriously delinquent rate, at 7.87%, up 18 basis points. That measure covers loans 60 or more days delinquent, loans in foreclosure, real estate owned properties and non-performing matured balloon loans.

CRE Daily gives the year-ago headline rate as 7.23%, and 7.55% six months earlier.

Earlier in the year, Trepp's June 2026 report gave a headline rate of 7.35%, down 20 basis points from May, and a seriously delinquent rate of 7.16%, down from 7.3% in May.

In the Trepp reports cited here, the two measures sit between 0.15 and 0.2 percentage points apart. Readers comparing months should check which rate a report leads with.

Past-Maturity Loans Sit Outside the Headline

Loans that are past their maturity date but still current on interest are classed as performing matured balloons. Trepp leaves them out of the headline rate and reports them in a separate figure.

Including them would have changed the September 2026 figure to 9.66%, down 15 basis points from August, according to CRE Daily's summary. In June, the same measure with those loans included stood at 9.53%, up 36 basis points from May, per Trepp's report.

Non-performing matured balloon loans made up most of the newly delinquent balances in September. Non-performing matured balloon loans accounted for 68%, against 19% for foreclosures and 13% for 30-day delinquencies.

Five large loans were newly delinquent in the month. They were an eight-property studio-and-office portfolio in Los Angeles at $1.10 billion, a two-tower office complex in Houston at $470.0 million, a beachfront hotel in Santa Monica at $280.0 million, an office loan in Denver at $230.1 million and a single-tenant office loan in Silicon Valley at $208.9 million.

The largest cure of the month was a $384.3 million office tower in Los Angeles. It moved back to performing matured balloon status after the borrower resumed interest-only payments, according to CRE Daily.

Office and Multifamily Rates in the September Report

The office rate in the September report was 12.16%, up 16 basis points. The CMBS 2.0+ office rate was 12.09%. In June, the office rate stood at 11.57%, up 4 basis points from May.

Multifamily was 8.04%, up 35 basis points and above the 6.59% reading of a year earlier. The CMBS 2.0+ multifamily rate was 8.06%.

Other property types moved in different directions. Lodging rose 34 basis points to 6.18%, while retail fell 62 basis points to 6.58% after three large malls cured or paid off. Industrial was 1.14%, unchanged.

Across the CMBS 2.0+ universe, the delinquency rate was 7.93%, up 17 basis points. Foreclosures were 2.90% of the CMBS universe and real estate owned properties 1.46%.

Why Trepp Has Kept the Treatment Since Before the Last Downturn

National Mortgage News reported on March 7, 2012 that Trepp had set the practice before the downturn, when relatively few loans fell into the category. Manus Clancy, a Trepp senior managing director, said the company kept the treatment so that its current statistics would remain comparable with its historic data.

For February 2012, Trepp reported a headline rate of 9.37%. Including performing matured balloons, the rate was 10.57%, up 22 basis points for the month. The gap between the two measures was 1.2 percentage points.

The same article describes a large number of five-year loans from the boom reaching maturity at that time.

The September 2026 headline uses the same exclusion, with the inclusive figure reported alongside it.

“The headline is only the starting point, because each figure beside it counts late loans in a different way.”

How MBA's Commercial Delinquency Report Splits the Market by Lender

The Mortgage Bankers Association reports delinquency rates by capital source. Its Q2 2025 figures, released on Sept. 15, 2025, were measured on an unpaid principal balance basis, and each group had its own threshold.

CMBS loans were counted at 30 or more days delinquent or in real estate owned status. Life company portfolios were counted at 60 or more days, and banks and thrifts at 90 or more days or in non-accrual. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were counted at 60 or more days, though Fannie Mae counts loans in payment forbearance as delinquent and Freddie Mac excludes them if the borrower complies with the forbearance agreement.

The Q2 2025 rates were 6.36% for CMBS, up 0.45 percentage points from Q1 2025, 0.51% for life companies, 1.29% for banks and thrifts, 0.61% for Fannie Mae and 0.47% for Freddie Mac. MBA states that the rates are not directly comparable across groups.

For Q2 2026, ConnectCRE's account of the MBA data, published Oct. 1, 2026, gives a CMBS rate of 6.53%, an improvement of 42 basis points. Banks and thrifts were at 1.20%, down 4 basis points. Life companies were at 0.48%, Fannie Mae at 0.60% and Freddie Mac at 0.51%, each increasing modestly, and all three remain below 1%.

The thresholds above come from the 2025 release. The sources used here do not confirm them for the 2026 series.

On multifamily, MBA associate vice president of commercial real estate research Reggie Booker said delinquencies are higher than in the recent past but still in the middle of the historical range for the government-sponsored enterprises. Booker also pointed to a tough combination of higher interest rates and flat or declining effective rents in a number of markets. Some owners are refinancing successfully, while others are struggling to find financing.

MBA's 2025 figures used an unpaid principal balance basis and come from a different publisher than Trepp, so the 6.53% and the 7.35% are separate series.

Reading a Monthly Report Without Mixing Measures

Four checks help when reading a monthly release. Each one is a matter of matching like with like.

First, identify the headline rate and the seriously delinquent rate. In Trepp's September 2026 data they are 8.02% and 7.87%, and a comparison with a prior month should use the same line.

Second, check whether performing matured balloons are included. The inclusive measure was 9.66% in September and 9.53% in June, well above the headline figures of 8.02% and 7.35%.

Third, match the report month and the publisher. CRE Daily summarized Trepp's September figures on Oct. 5, so a trend should be built from one publisher's series.

Fourth, keep lender groups apart. MBA reports CMBS, life company, bank and agency rates as separate series, each with its own threshold.

The headline is only the starting point, because each figure beside it counts late loans in a different way.


Related